Other Articles in this Category
Most Viewed Stories
Most Commented Stories
Save & Share this Article
A 'SYMBOLIC BLOCKADE' IN DESTIN: Fishermen rally against amberjack lockdown (UPDATED with PHOTOS)
DESTIN — Horns, waves, signs and shouts greeted motorists on the Marler Bridge on Saturday as more than 100 boats gathered in East Pass to rally for fishermen.
The vessels, including about 70 charter boats, formed a “symbolic blockade of the East Pass on the harbor,” said Mike Eller, co-president of the Destin Charter Boat Association, which organized the local flotilla.
Fishermen also rallied in Panama City, Mexico Beach and Orange Beach, Ala., to publicize how closing the red snapper and amberjack seasons has affected their livelihoods and the problems with how data is collected to support the decision.
People stood along Marler Bridge’s walkway and waved signs to ask for support from motorists as boats converged in the pass.
For more photos of the protest from Log photographer Kathy Harrison, click here.
Jami Jones, who owns Destin Charter and Adventure Charter at Fleet Marina, has been in the business for 10 years. But she stood on the bridge rather than join her fellow charter boat owners on the water because she had to leave for her second job because of the financial strain caused by the restrictions.
“It’s crippling the entire industry,” she said of the snapper and amberjack season closings. “The data doesn’t support what they are saying. We need to do whatever we can. These guys are going out of business. They’ve been doing this for generations and want to pass the trade on to their sons, but this is shutting them down.”
The National Marine Fisheries Service, which governs the recreational and commercial fishing industries, announced the closing of snapper season Sept. 20 and the amberjack season Oct. 24, based on surveys taken.
The Marine Recreational Fishery Statistics Survey was implemented in 1979 by the Fisheries Service to establish a database to estimate the impact of recreational fishing on marine resources. The survey is conducted in all coastal states. The information is used by federal and state agencies to formulate fishery management plans, evaluate future demands on fish stocks and predict and evaluate the impact of fishery regulations.
Estimates generated from the survey include the total number of fish caught, released and harvested; the weight of the harvest; total number of angler trips; and number of people participating in marine recreational fishing.
Local fishermen believe the survey is flawed and eventually will lead more restrictions despite larger fish populations, Eller said.
Norm Hall, a member of the Kelly Plantation Fishing Club, said he retired to Destin for the beach and the fishing.
“We want to make sure public officials understand the impact that poorly made decisions have had on the economic situation,” he said as he stood on the bridge. “We, as recreational fishermen, may not have moved here in the Northwest Florida region had we known these regulations were coming.”
After the blockade, hundreds of people gathered for Destin’s Silver Jubilee fish fry and a protest rally Eller called both educational and motivational.
“We want to draw people’s attention to the literature,” Eller said. “We’re hoping to get Congress to fund a third-party independent stock assessment, which costs around $5 million. We also want them to fund a new recreational data system.”
Several charter boat owners hope for “real-time data,” or information delivered immediately after it is collected, to be put in place. Tracy Redding, owner of AAA Charters in Alabama, said real-time data would allow fisheries officials to know when they are approaching the quota and allow for planning for contingencies.
“We’re trying to think outside of the box,” Redding said.
Destin Mayor Craig Barker came Saturday for a celebration of Destin’s history, which he said was an unfortunate coincidence.
“I think it’s ironic that we’re here celebrating Destin’s history and heritage when our history and heritage is being threatened,” Barker said. “Our message is that the scientific data they are using to monitor fish stock is fatally flawed. The last eight years we’ve called on Congress to appropriate resources to do a full-blown stock assessment.”
Elected officials at the federal and state levels are aware of the problems, they say.
“I think (rallying) is an excellent idea, I support everyone’s right to protect their industry. Right now, I’m working on the Marine Fisheries to overturn or open up the seasons,” U.S. Rep. Jeff Miller said in a telephone interview Friday. “I’m now focusing on the next year’s season of grouper, amberjack and snapper.”
State Sen. Don Gaetz also has been trying to change policies to give fisheries managers more time and money.
“Fishing isn’t just a way of life in Florida,” Gaetz said Friday. “It’s a major driver of our economy, particularly along the Gulf Coast.”
As charter boat owners stepped up on the stage at Fishermen’s Wharf on Saturday, they said the protest only is their first step in what they know will be a long fight.
“We have to keep the momentum rolling,” said George Eller, a charter boat captain for more than 30 years. “This is a good start. This is a good step. It’s more than just a baby step. We need to do whatever it takes to right the wrongs.”
Unifying fishermen and rallying for new policies and legislative support will be a continuing effort, Mike Eller said.
“The only fix is help from congressional leaders,” he said. “This is not just a local problem, it’s up and down the Atlantic Seaboard. It’s really everywhere. We’ve got a lot of energy and effort going into this.
“People are fired up because what’s been done is not fair. It’s not right,” Eller said.
For still more photos from the protest, click here.
Watch a video of the Destin flotilla and rally »
This report comes from Pam Anderson, operations manager at Capt. Anderson Marina in Panama City Beach:
"I want to take a minute and thank all who took part in or had a part in making the Fishermen's Rallies here on the Gulf Coast a success today. In our area, we would have rather had more private recreational anglers come out with us, but we still had a great turnout.
We had almost 70% of the for-hire boats come out in the Panama City area. Between Orange Beach, Pensacola, Destin, Panama City, Mexico Beach and Pt. St. Joe, there were more that 250 boats out and over 250 people out on the bridges waiving their banners. (There are only 1100+ permitted boats across the entire Gulf coast!) We truly appreciate the support and know it will help us make a difference in the regulations that we need to have changed.
We will continue to forge ahead and work toward getting the proper legislation passed so everyone can either get back to work in the industry, or get out and enjoy the sport of fishing on their own boats.
Keep your legislators' mailboxes busy..."
To read more about the rally in PCB, click here.
Be sure to tell us what you think. Post your comments at the bottom of this story!
See archived 'News' stories »
| I dont remeber the name of the gentleman but he wears a noaa hat and has a pony tail. He collects our catch sheets. He is also the man that does our dockside survey. I did take it personally and got a little defensive. Its a issue that people get on here that have no idea what is going on and they try to tell us whats going on out there when we are the one that experience it the most. |
|
| adestinfisherman - Nov 13, 2009 10:17:39 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| adestinfisherman, sorry my ignorance offends you, I certainly didn't mean any insult. My time is very limited, and I am trying to help you as I worked as a NMFS agent, lived in Destin, and I manage data. I've been abroad for years, so yes I'm ignorant of YOUR activities, but do not assume I cannot assist you, and your cause. And please note that my second post was specifically NOT addressed to you or anyone personally, it was simply a general observation about why collectively 'your' justifications are ineffective with gov officials. I understand how and why you took it personally, as this is both a trying time, and a difficult venue to discern inflection, intent, and a constructive critisism from insult. Now, while I eat my lunch, may I ask where you file your catch data because you each have posts mentioning filing your data with NOAA, FWC, and NMFS. Or, please feel free to tell me again that it's none of my business, and I will not help you further. Either way you have my blessings. |
|
| Kay - Nov 13, 2009 02:53:28 AM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| Kay I dont know where you get off coming on here and telling us what to do when you dont even know what it is we do to count fish. Then your vast knowlage of the issue shows brightly when you tell us to do something that we already doing. You got some nerve. |
|
| adestinfisherman - Nov 13, 2009 12:08:57 AM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| Oh and Kay your brutal honesty as you put it shows your brutal ingnorance of the issue you speak of. I have taken six observers on over twenty five trips this year. I have filled out every trip sheet for every trip I have ran and turned them in to NOAA. I have and continue to do my part on counting fish. When I reffer to my heritage and my livelyhood I speak on behalf of all my fellow fisherman in this industry and this town. I am a honest man as my family and friends raised me to be and dont like it when someone who doesnt know me emplys that I have not been truthful in my loggings. We have the best snapper stock that anyone out there has seen in over thirty years. While this is great the lack of harvesting these fish are having a direct impact on other reef fish. The groupers have become scarce in this area of the gulf due to the enormous snapper population. There is only so much bait supply and if we let these fish over populate then they will run off every other reef fish that has a less aggresive feeding habbits than they do. See its easy to sit behind your computer and spout off about what you think is right but it doesnt matter when your ideas dont even scrach the surface of reality. Please get informed and try not to hurt yourself when you get off the soap box your standing on. |
|
| adestinfisherman - Nov 12, 2009 11:52:46 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| I run a party boat out of destin. And Kay I do fill out a trip sheet everytime I go fishing. Its not about me its about us I agree. But you have to understand because apperently you have never had to deal with the NMFS. They will not accept your at home internet reporting. That is not valid science to these people. They are not going to get into a hurry to impliment any kind of data system. Why? I dont know maybe it will show how poor their job performance is or it might not go along with the lobbying that they have excepted. What I can tell you is that the data system they are using is out dated and was developed to monitor fishing trends not take stock assesments and not to shut down fishing communities. |
|
| adestinfisherman - Nov 12, 2009 11:38:38 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| Excuse me, all you that think you know so much about what the charter people are doing. As a charter boat owner I report to FWC every single week about how many trips I've run, how long they were, what waters we fish in, the minimum depth, max. depth, how many hours of actual fishing time, how many anglers, how many of each kind of fish caught, released, kept, how many swam away getting the picture?
So we are doing everything we can and as well as offering to let any of the officials ride with us at any time to really see what is going on. Haven't seen anyone hopping on board yet but wouldn't you think they'd want to if they really want the truth? |
|
| afishhead - Nov 12, 2009 07:52:18 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| Kay, who are you? Where do you get your information regarding fish counts and internet reporting. Why don't you just come out and say that you are a fish hugging liberal. |
|
| kgd - Nov 12, 2009 03:33:29 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| Forgive my brutal honesty in mentioning that recent protests are VERY telling since your complaints and substantiations ALWAYS center around YOU, your livelihood, your heritage, your rights, your business, your money, your sons, your boats, your needs, BUT frankly this ISSUE is not about YOU, it's about OUR FISH which belong to, and feed an entire nation. OUR FISH are a limited resource that must be managed for sustainability, and to prevent desired species from being hunted to extinction. If you want to save your industry, then you'de be smart to feed data to the fisheries so they can make wise decisions on your behalf, which also separates your catch from the overfishing by the commercial fishing industry! And believe it or not, most every environmentalist and 'liberal idiot' will be first in line to help you! Or are you really afraid to acknowledge that our fish stocks are not growing, and there are not that many fish left in the sea? |
|
| Kay - Nov 09, 2009 10:34:50 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| to adestinfisherman, Don't wait for THEM, take action NOW by recording your catch and trip data yourselves, and present it weekly to both the NMF and State Reps, exactly like your fisheries agent did in the past! Your documentation cannot be ignored or destroyed once it's registered formally 'on paper'. To be effective, ALL charters in each sector must participate daily, by completing detailed count sheets, signed by two witnesses at landing. Fortunately the Internet makes it easy and cheap to implement, maintain, publish a tally online, while allowing ALL recreational fisherman to enter their catch via home computers as well. Charter count sheets can be entered individually or en mass, then filed and re-submitted to NMF and State Reps monthly by both the City Council and Charter Boat Assn, etc. The more 'qualified' data that arrives, the quicker the NMF will kick into gear to implement a new system, and they will eventually migrate you "over to their system' as no one wants to ignore continuous pertinent qualified data, which is invaluable! Remember, the key to data collection is collecting it AND validating it at the source. So, can we count on all our local fisherman to take the lead in saving this industry by providing honest counts and validation of their daily catch? Or have fisherman already decided that YOUR catch is really none of OUR business? |
|
| Kay - Nov 09, 2009 10:03:21 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| Sharkbait I do want them to renourish the beach. One for the tourist. The other to keep our insurance premiums from rising from the unevitable claims that will happen sooner than later. And to protect the people whose property is in great peril. |
|
| adestinfisherman - Nov 09, 2009 03:01:52 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| The fishermen are hurting and we want them to be able to make a living here in Destin. A huge impediment to their livelihood is the feds and their regulations that are off target. Another impediment is the lack of beach on Holiday Isle. There are thousands of vacationers who come to Destin for the beaches. When they get here the husband goes off with the son to fish, maybe more than once. Strongly recommend the fishing boat captains give their full support to beach renourishment in Destin. |
|
| Sharkbait - Nov 09, 2009 02:16:22 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| Kay they wont set up the system. We want to be accountable in our fishing efforts. They wont set it up. We have been asking for this for years. And nothing! Please help us they wont take the info if we just call it in. There is no way to verify that is what they caught. This is what they have said to that idea. They dont want to fix it that would go against the lobbiest that they have been padding the pockets of these crooks at the NMFS. Surf dweller you sir should never wish for bad things to happen. It might happen to you. |
|
| adestinfisherman - Nov 09, 2009 11:55:42 AM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| Save money. Toss a line over your privacy fence and your friend can tie a brick on your line. I think Barrack should make all fishing illegal or at least make you pay taxes on the fish you catch.
Okay, I'm just kidding ! |
|
| richard - Nov 09, 2009 11:49:49 AM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| If the data is so misconstrued, then why aren't fisherman even trying to correct catch data so it accurately represents your take? Fisherman can easily call in their daily trip and catch data to a central database so the sector count and weights can be tallied. Or is this too much to ask from fishermen who take of hundreds of thousands of pounds of OUR natural resources FOR FREE? |
|
| Kay - Nov 09, 2009 10:00:53 AM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| surf dweller the only idiot i see is you. We were here long before you and will be here long after you are gone. |
|
| Destin captain - Nov 09, 2009 05:06:22 AM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| These idoits belong in the same class with JE and DP. I hope a big storm puts them all under. |
|
| Surf Dweller - Nov 08, 2009 08:11:59 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| Defender thank you for your support. But dont let anyone throw up a smoke screen. The enviromentalist are behind highly restrictive fisheries managment tactics. They were the lead lobbiest behind the reautho of the Magnuson Stevens Act. FACT! |
|
| adestinfisherman - Nov 08, 2009 07:02:14 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| I am a forhire fisheram and captain of a partyboat in destin. I can start the list of enviros that are behind this. The enviromental defense fund. The Pew Trust. These are the major two enviro groups lobbying for catch shares. A goverment program that limits the access of fisheries to future business owners. Dont let the sheets get pulled over you head on this one. They are lobbying for highly restrictive fishing regulation. Their reasoning behind this? They want to limit the amount of people that can access the fisheries. By doing that it will be easier to regulate. I dont know who told you that the enviros arent behind this but you should look over your shoulder and dont pay anymore attention to person that is filling your head with this smoke screen keeping you from seeing the truth. |
|
| adestinfisherman - Nov 08, 2009 06:45:31 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| Let's not be blaming 'enviromentalists' for the evil of a government bureacracy. I don't know a single enviro who is against the fishermen on this. Knowing your planet -and coast- means knowing the science. When the NMFS uses blatantly outdated data and formulas we must stand WITH our fishermen and captains. Not against them. The NMFS must come up with the funding and the current scientific data if they wish to make a case. All boat's catches must be counted equally and no boats should be limited with out proven science to back it up. Please Support our Destin Fleet. |
|
| defender - Nov 08, 2009 03:46:08 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |
| You may block it now but Obama Hussien is sending in a big storm to wash you away while shouting Ala akbar or whatever in the passing of his health thing. |
|
| Calvin - Nov 08, 2009 12:17:59 PM | Remove Comment |
| | |




