Subscribe to the Newspaper
View the Online Newspaper
Welcome
Search: Site   Web
Print Story | E-Mail Story | Font Size
What is this?

Save & Share this Article

Gusty Gustav takes a bite out of Destin's beaches (with video)

Destin’s infrastructure came through Hurricane Gustav just fine, city officials say, but the beaches are another story.

“Most of the sand we’ve placed behind Jetty East and Destin Pointe is pretty well gone,” City Manager Greg Kisela told The Log, “but you’d expect that ... The brunt of the damage is to the beaches.”

Otherwise, Kisela said, the city seems to have taken little damage: Even a waterspout over the Marler Bridge didn’t wreak any havoc. The winds did take their toll on the local power grid as about 506 Okaloosa County customers, including Destin homes, were plunged into darkness at about 10 a.m. But it was a far cry from the nearly 1 million that are without power across Louisiana after the Category Two storm roared ashore in central Louisiana. Locally, power was restored quickly and all but 15 homes were restored by 7 p.m.

“So that’s a normal day for us,” said John Hutchinson, Gulf Power spokesman. Hutchinson added that the company is sending 51 workers to the strike zone to help the CLECO power company restore power to Opelousas and Lafayette.

As with Hurricanes Katrina and Dennis in 2005, however, the Gulf waters stirred up by the storm ate away at the city’s waterfront.

“We have waves that were probably 14 to 15 feet high for 24 hours,” said Jerry Stalnaker, the manager of Jetty East Condominiums. “They took out the cap of our seawall, took out the stairs to our beach and did significant damage to our pavilion.”

Earlier this year, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers had more than 30,000 cubic yards of sand dredged to the end of Holiday Isle. Contractors then worked 16,000 cubic yards into a protective berm for those beaches.

Stalnaker and Terry Trojan of Destin Pointe said that without the berm, the damage could have been far worse.

“It saved us and Destin Pointe from horrendous damage,” Stalnaker said.

“I’ve seen pictures,” Trojan, who’s currently out of town, told The Log. “The water did get up to the pool, there’s some sand and windblown debris ... The temporary berm that was put up did the job of protecting the property this time. Most of it is gone now (and) folks are concerned about the next storm.”

And with three named storms brewing, who knows when that hurricane could be.

“I think that unfortunately these storms over the last three or four years have prepared us for some pretty bad stuff,” said Kisela. “We need to get Holiday Isle some badly-needed storm protection, because God forbid we got a direct hit, we’d lose every ounce of sand.”

Some visitors to Crystal Beach last week told The Log that the restored beaches there have also been eaten away by normal tides and time in the year since the sand was placed.

Okaloosa County Beach Projects Coordinator Jim Trifilio told The Log that if a restored beach is eroded, the Federal Emergency Management Agency has a program that will pay to rebuild it, but only in emergencies.

“If there was an emergency, what FEMA would do is restore the beach to what it was just before the storm,” Trifilio said. If the restored beach had been eroding for 20 years before the storm, none of that would be rebuilt, he said.

Okaloosa County is also trying to enter the federal Storm Protection Program, Trifilio added, which would rebuild the beach to the original design, no matter how much it has eroded since.


See archived 'News' Stories »
 

Click to vote
Recommend this story?
Yes
No
The online vote: 3 2


Reader's comments




Earlier this year the army corp of engineers and the city of Destin spent taxpayer money to give more sand to the west part of Destin. Destin Pointe, one of the few places that appears to favor restoration, received the same special deal as hotels. Their residents are only paying about half the beach tax as most of the rest of us who do not want or need the project. I see no one has answered the earlier question. Just how much of their own money have these properties spent on sand?

Paid too much already - Sep 05, 2008 12:04:29 AM Remove Comment

 
PT is right, but it isn’t just the tractor. Between the tractor, sheriff, beach vendors, and especially the lifeguards, there are tire tracks everywhere on Okaloosa Island. Instead of REstoring the beach on Okaloosa Island the county should just stop DEstroying the beach on Okaloosa Island.

Common Sense - Sep 04, 2008 09:46:11 PM Remove Comment

 
Okaloosa Island beaches came through Gustav just fine too. Buildings on the island all high and dry. Water never came past the dunes. In fact, Gustav added to the dunes. Seems like the rest of us are getting forced into this MSBU to subsidize two properties with chronic problems. They never did answer the prior reader who asked just how much of their own money they have spent on sand.

The Borg - Sep 04, 2008 09:33:03 PM Remove Comment

 
Each owner at Island Mist condo on Okaloosa island pays 481 dollars a year. Island Mist sits on 79 feet of public beach frontage with a wide, white beach. Each owner at Magnolia House, condo in Destin Pointe, pays 55 dollars. Magnolia House sits on 300 feet of private beach frontage that needs restoration. Why do those who dont need restoration pay the most? Make Destin Pointe pay their fair share.

Okaloosa county math - Sep 04, 2008 09:13:19 PM Remove Comment

 
Mr. Guidry thank you for the photos and information. Gustav did NOT take a bite out of Destin Beaches as the Log's headline suggests. Our beach is also fine and Mother Nature is rebuilding it. We also spent thousands of dollars on beach repair and dune construction after Ivan. Storms continue to assualt Jetty East and Destin Pointe. Those were the beaches bitten once again. Just how much of THEIR OWN MONEY have they spent in sand repair and dune construction?

just the beginning - Sep 04, 2008 10:43:25 AM Remove Comment

 
"Sick", most of the people who are concerned about this "restoration" project get their facts from direct observation and careful research. This whole scheme is nothing more than an attempt to make the beaches public. If the county, city, or tourist council cared a bit about the health of the beach that destructive tractor would not have been raping the beach all these years and it would have a chance to rebuild itself in a sustainable way as nature intended.

pt - Sep 03, 2008 03:58:39 PM Remove Comment

 
Go to web site guidry dot ws to view a slide show narrative of Oceanias beach as Gustav came in and did its thing and went away. the Oceania Owners spent a lot of money after Ivan and Dennis building our dunes, planting sea oats, and nurturing our dunes since then to enhance growth. It paid off, we had no damage. It shows what can happen if a condo takes care of itself. Spend the money on the beaches that really needs renourishment and leave us alone. The TDC has enought money to restore the beaches that really need it without the unwanted illegal inequitable tax.

Roland Guidry - Sep 03, 2008 02:37:18 PM Remove Comment

 
There are not a lot of experts on beach restoration. That's the problem. Local and state leaders are willing to try unproven methods while wasting millions of tax dollars. One well recognized expert is Dr. Orin Pilkey from Duke University who says restored beaches erode 2 to 10 times more quickly than those left in a natural state. We need to know the results and risks of beach restoration before we continue to spend millions and millions of tax dollars on unproven methods.

Beachykeen - Sep 03, 2008 12:27:13 PM Remove Comment

 
Regarding the sand source being darker than native sand, I quote FDEP and Taylor Engineering. Request for Additional Information 0286020 001 JC, Okaloosa County Okaloosa Island , FDEP asks “Please justify the color limit of 5Y 6 slash 2 or lighter. Is a moist 7 slash 2 or lighter limit not attainable?“ The Taylor Engineering Okaloosa Island Beach Management Feasibility Study, November 2007, states “native beach color 5Y 8 slash 1 or lighter“ and “Okaloosa island sand is 8 and a half.” Why should we accept a 6, when Cocoa Beach is a 6 and a half, Pensacola Beach is 9 and a quarter, and sugar is 10?

knowledge is power - Sep 03, 2008 12:07:31 PM Remove Comment

 
Regarding the proposed sand source being more coarse than native sand, I quote FDEP. "Request for Additional Information 0286020 001 JC, Okaloosa County Okaloosa Island. Regarding the Sediment Characteristics table, Table 1, Attachment G, Please justify the upper limit of the mean grain size range. From the information presented on the borrow area, an upper limit of point sixty millimeters seems rather coarse. Native sand is point thirty four millimeters."

Just the facts - Sep 03, 2008 11:56:43 AM Remove Comment

 
Restored beaches degrade 2 to 10 times more quickly than native beaches, source Dr. Orrin Pilkey, Duke University.

teacher - Sep 03, 2008 11:48:23 AM Remove Comment

 
And what makes you all the experts on beach renourishment and erosion? Where do you get your "facts" from?

Sick of you know it alls - Sep 03, 2008 10:59:58 AM Remove Comment

 
The powers to be pushed beach restoration saying once it was done the federal government would rebuild it when and if needed. The federal government has no "Destin White Sand Beach Ordinance". They are not concerned about sand color and will deliver what ever sand they choose. If you don't believe me just call DEP/ Beach Management and ask them. Just make sure you speak to someone who actually knows and will give you an honest answer. There are plenty of people in local and state government that refuse to tell the truth about beach restoration.

Beachykeen - Sep 03, 2008 09:54:27 AM Remove Comment

 
Restored beaches erode at 2 to 10 times the rate of natural beaches. The natural beaches of Destin and Okaloosa island had no problem.

sand lover - Sep 02, 2008 02:41:21 PM Remove Comment
 

Add your comments
Please follow and enforce these guidelines:
1. No flaming. Do not be hostile.
2. No comments that are obscene, vulgar, lewd, sexually-oriented, threatening, libelous, or illegal.
3. No racial slurs or insults.
4. "Remove Comment" flags offensive comment for removal.

Verification Code:
Enter Verification:
Your Name:
Your Comment:
By submitting this form, you agree to this site's terms of service




Jobs
Autos
Real Estate
Classifieds
Today's Ads
Search for Jobs - Monster.com
   
Weather
Yellow Pages
ADVERTISEMENT 
ADVERTISEMENT 
THIS WEEK'S POLL
In light of the recent Supreme Court decision on beach restoration, should the county scrap its plans to tax beachfront owners in a special assessment?
Yes
No
Enter The Code To Vote
 
powered by
google
Search
        Search: Web    Site